Nolly.com is listed by the IRS as a Certifying Acceptance Agent in Canada.See the listing
  1. Home
  2. Guides
  3. 1040-NR vs 1040: Which Return Should You File?
Tax returns

1040-NR vs 1040: Which Return Should You File?

1040-NR vs 1040: how the green card test and substantial presence test set your status, what each return covers, and how to avoid filing the wrong form.

Published by Nolly.comUpdated 6 min read
A woman at a kitchen table sorts printed forms beside a laptop in afternoon window light.
On this page8 sections
  1. How the two residency tests decide the form
  2. Form 1040 vs Form 1040-NR side by side
  3. What income Form 1040-NR reports for a nonresident
  4. Who must file Form 1040-NR
  5. When a nonresident can file Form 1040 instead
  6. Filing the wrong form: mismatches to check
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Have your 1040-NR prepared by Nolly.com

Form 1040-NR is the return for nonresident aliens, and Form 1040 is the return for people treated as U.S. residents. In the 1040-NR vs 1040 question, the deciding factor is residency status for tax purposes. The IRS treats an alien who has not passed the green card test or the substantial presence test as a nonresident alien.

Picking the form comes after working out status for the year. This guide covers how that status points to a form, what income Form 1040-NR reports, when a nonresident can file Form 1040 through a spouse election, and the mismatches that lead to the wrong return.

How the two residency tests decide the form

The IRS defines an alien as any individual who is not a U.S. citizen or U.S. national. For aliens, tax status turns on two tests: the green card test and the substantial presence test. An alien who has not passed either test is a nonresident alien. The order of checks looks like this:

  1. Confirm the person is an alien, meaning not a U.S. citizen or U.S. national.
  2. Check the green card test for the tax year.
  3. Check the substantial presence test for the tax year.
  4. If neither test is passed, the person is a nonresident alien, and non-residents file on Form 1040-NR, not Form 1040.

The IRS keeps separate topics for the harder cases, including determining alien tax status, residency starting and ending dates, dual status aliens, exempt individuals who are students, and conditions for a closer connection to a foreign country. It also lists Publication 519, U.S. Tax Guide for Aliens, among its forms. Unusual situations should be checked against those IRS pages.

Form 1040 vs Form 1040-NR side by side

The two returns use the same tax rates for some income, but they serve different filers and treat income from U.S. sources differently. The table sets out the points the IRS page on nonresident aliens addresses.

PointForm 1040Form 1040-NR
Who files itResident aliens and others treated as U.S. residentsNonresident aliens

The practical difference sits in the last row. A nonresident with only passive U.S. income does not get deductions against it, and the tax is often taken at source by the payer. The return then reconciles what was withheld against what was owed.

What income Form 1040-NR reports for a nonresident

The first is effectively connected income, earned by a nonresident alien engaged in a trade or business in the United States. The IRS taxes it, after allowable deductions, at the same rates that apply to U.S. citizens and residents.

The second is U.S.-source income that is fixed, determinable, annual, or periodical, often shortened to FDAP. When the nonresident is not engaged in a trade or business, the IRS taxes this income at a flat 30% or a lower treaty rate, and no deductions are allowed against it.

The IRS notes that one person can earn both kinds in the same year, and each is taxed under its own rule. Our guide on effectively connected income versus FDAP walks through how income is sorted between the two.

Who must file Form 1040-NR

Being a nonresident alien does not by itself create a filing duty. The IRS page lists three situations in which a nonresident alien must file a return:

  • The person was engaged, or considered to be engaged, in a trade or business in the United States during the year.
  • The person had U.S. income on which the tax liability was not satisfied by withholding at the source, even without a U.S. trade or business.
  • The person wants to claim a refund of excess withholding, or wants the benefit of deductions or credits.

The IRS gives an example for the third case: a nonresident with rental property income who chooses to treat that income as connected to a trade or business. That choice brings the income under the effectively connected rules, so deductions can be claimed against it, and a return is how the claim is made. For a fuller walk-through of these triggers, see do you need to file a 1040-NR.

When a nonresident can file Form 1040 instead

There is one route on the IRS page by which a nonresident alien ends up on Form 1040. It applies to married couples where one spouse is a resident alien and the other is not.

If a person is a nonresident alien at the end of the tax year and their spouse is a resident alien, the spouse can choose to treat them as a U.S. resident alien for tax purposes. The couple then files Form 1040 using the filing status Married Filing Jointly.

Two points follow from the wording. First, it is a choice, so without it the nonresident spouse’s status stays nonresident. Second, it depends on the other spouse being a resident alien at the time described. The IRS has a separate topic on a nonresident alien spouse treated as a resident alien, and another on electing head of household status with a nonresident alien spouse. Our guide on filing a joint return with a foreign spouse covers the ITIN side of this election.

Filing the wrong form: mismatches to check

Most wrong-form problems come from a mismatch between status and the return chosen. Each item below can be checked against the IRS page before anything is sent:

  • A nonresident alien using Form 1040 without a spouse election. Non-residents file on Form 1040-NR, not Form 1040.
  • Treating the spouse election as automatic. The IRS wording is that the resident spouse can choose it.
  • Skipping a return because there was no U.S. business, when withholding at source did not cover the tax owed on U.S. income.
  • Not filing at all when too much was withheld. A return is how a refund of excess withholding is claimed.
  • Claiming deductions against FDAP income, which the IRS says are not allowed against it.

Settling residency status first, using the two tests, removes most of these mismatches before the return is prepared.

Frequently asked questions

The IRS says a nonresident alien must file a return to claim a refund of excess withholding. Form 1040-NR is the return used for that claim. Whether any amount comes back depends on the income, the withholding and the rules that apply, and the IRS decides the outcome after processing the return.

The seller claims credit for FIRPTA withholding on Form 1040-NR. The buyer reports and pays the withholding with Forms 8288 and 8288-A. FIRPTA withholding is generally 15% of the amount realized, with lower or no withholding in some cases where the buyer will use the property as a home.

A Form W-7 normally goes in with the federal tax return unless an exception applies. A valid passport is the only stand-alone identity document. A Certifying Acceptance Agent, such as Nolly.com, verifies identity documents and sends the application to the IRS. See how to file a 1040-NR online.

Yes. An ITIN that is not used on a federal tax return for three consecutive years expires. A nonresident who files Form 1040-NR only occasionally should check whether the number is still active before the next return. The IRS charges no fee for an ITIN.

Have your 1040-NR prepared by Nolly.com

Nolly.com is an IRS Certifying Acceptance Agent in Toronto. We prepare your U.S. non-resident tax return from your income documents, and you review and sign it before we file. Get your 1040-NR prepared. Form 1040-NR preparation at Nolly.com is $150, or $349 with the ITIN application.

Source: IRS.gov, Nonresident aliens.

This guide is general information, not tax advice. Rules change and every situation is different, so check the IRS page above or ask a qualified tax professional about your own case.

Published November 13, 2026. General information, not tax advice. Nolly Services Inc is a private company and is not part of the IRS.